Universal Kernel

new object

Which objects does a double cover add to those of the group below it?

A transitive set of the double cover SL⁡(2,7)\SL(2,7) on which −I-I acts without fixed points, so that it comes from no set of the group of order 168; there are exactly four, one over each class of subgroups of odd order.

new objects of sl(2,7), two to one onto the object beneath168184C256C324C742C41G28S314A4b7S4b7S4a14A4a21D842V4b42V4a87:33361124816
Plate 1.6The four objects whose stabilizer has odd order, 1, C3C_3, C7C_7 and 7:37{:}3: over each the double cover adds one new object, of size 336, 112, 48 or 16.
Definition(New objects)

Write G~=SL⁡(2,7)\tilde G=\SL(2,7) and π ⁣:G~→G\pi\colon\tilde G\to G for the map to Möbius transformations, a surjection with kernel {±I}\{\pm I\}; every GG-set is a G~\tilde G-set through π\pi. A G~\tilde G-set is pulled back if −I-I acts on it trivially, so that it comes from a GG-set through π\pi. A transitive G~\tilde G-set that is not pulled back is a new object.

The question comes from the negative space: SL⁡(2,7)\SL(2,7) carries spinors that do not descend, since the spin bundle over the seven points is not equivariantly trivial. The new objects are what the double cover does to objects.

Theorem(The subgroups of SL⁡(2,7)\SL(2,7))

(a) −I-I is the only involution of G~\tilde G. (b) The subgroups of G~\tilde G containing −I-I are the 179 preimages π−1(H)\pi^{-1}(H). A subgroup not containing −I-I has odd order and is mapped by π\pi isomorphically onto a subgroup of odd order. For each of the 45 subgroups HH of GG of odd order, of orders 1, 3, 7 and 21, the elements of odd order of π−1(H)\pi^{-1}(H) form a subgroup H∘H^\circ, the odd lift of HH, the only subgroup of G~\tilde G mapped isomorphically onto HH. (c) The 224 subgroups of G~\tilde G form 19 conjugacy classes: the preimages of the fifteen classes of GG and the odd lifts of the classes 1, C3C_3, C7C_7, 7:37{:}3.

Proof

(a) An involution X≠±IX\neq\pm I would have eigenvalues 1 and −1-1, hence determinant −1-1. (b) A subgroup KK containing −I-I is π−1(π(K))\pi^{-1}(\pi(K)). If −I∉K-I\notin K, then KK has no involution, so ∣K∣|K| is odd by Cauchy’s theorem and π\pi is injective on KK; then π−1(π(K))=K×{±I}\pi^{-1}(\pi(K))=K\times\{\pm I\}, whose elements of odd order are exactly those of KK. That the odd lifts exist was checked by machine. (c) Conjugation in G~\tilde G acts through GG.

Theorem(The new objects)

The new objects of G~\tilde G are exactly the four sets G~/H∘\tilde G/H^\circ, for HH in the classes 1, C3C_3, C7C_7, 7:37{:}3. On each of them −I-I acts without fixed points, and the quotient by −I-I is the object G/HG/H.

Their sizes are 336, 112, 48 and 16, with automorphism groups G~\tilde G, C4C_4, C6C_6 and C2C_2. On F72\F_7^2 they are the bases (v,w)(v,w) with det⁡(v,w)=1\det(v,w)=1; the pairs (vˉ,wˉ)(\bar v,\bar w) of square classes with det⁡(v,w)\det(v,w) a nonzero square; the nonzero vectors; and the square classes {v,2v,4v}\{v,2v,4v\} of nonzero vectors, whose quotients by −I-I are the regular object, the ordered pairs of distinct points, the vectors up to sign and the points of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7). An object of G~\tilde G on which −I-I acts nontrivially lies over G/HG/H if and only if ∣H∣|H| is odd.

Proof

The stabilizers of G~/H∘\tilde G/H^\circ are the conjugates of H∘H^\circ, none of which contains −I-I; so −I-I fixes no point, and the quotient is G~/π−1(H)=G/H\tilde G/\pi^{-1}(H)=G/H. A transitive set whose stabilizers contain −I-I is pulled back. If ∣H∣|H| is even, HH contains an involution, whose preimages have order 4 and square −I-I, so every subgroup of π−1(H)\pi^{-1}(H) mapping onto HH contains −I-I. The automorphism group is π−1(NG(H))/H∘\pi^{-1}(N_G(H))/H^\circ, of order 2∣NG(H):H∣2|N_G(H):H|, cyclic in the three proper cases; this and the incarnations were checked by machine.

It is the general fact for central kernels: a central kernel of prime order acts on every transitive set either trivially or without fixed points.

Proposition(Automorphisms over the quotient)

For each new object X~\tilde X with quotient X=X~/{±I}X=\tilde X/\{\pm I\}, the map Aut⁡(X~)→Aut⁡(X)\Aut(\tilde X)\to\Aut(X) is onto, with kernel {1,−I}\{1,-I\}. On the nonzero vectors the automorphisms are the scalars F7×≅C6\F_7^\times\cong C_6, and the squares {1,2,4}\{1,2,4\} map isomorphically onto the automorphism group C3C_3 of the object of size 24: the extension splits. On the object of size 112 the map σ(vˉ,wˉ)=(wˉ,−v‾)\sigma(\bar v,\bar w)=(\bar w,\overline{-v}) generates the automorphism group and σ2\sigma^2 is the action of −I-I; below, σ\sigma induces the exchange (a,b)↦(b,a)(a,b)\mapsto(b,a) of ordered pairs of points, an involution, and every automorphism lying over it has order 4. On the regular object the automorphisms form G~\tilde G, and G~→G\tilde G\to G does not split.

So a cycle of seams whose monodromy on the ordered pairs of points is the exchange has, on the object of size 112, the monodromy σ±1\sigma^{\pm1}, and going around it twice gives −I-I, not the identity. This is the sign of a spinor, met in a seam system.

Proof

π\pi carries π−1(NG(H))/H∘\pi^{-1}(N_G(H))/H^\circ onto NG(H)/HN_G(H)/H with kernel generated by the image of −I-I. det⁡(w,−v)=det⁡(v,w)\det(w,-v)=\det(v,w), so σ\sigma maps the object to itself; it commutes with G~\tilde G because the action is linear, and σ2(vˉ,wˉ)=(−v‾,−w‾)\sigma^2(\bar v,\bar w)=(\overline{-v},\overline{-w}). A subgroup of order 168 of G~\tilde G would contain −I-I, and so be the preimage of a subgroup of order 84 of GG, of which there is none.

Proposition(The spinorial content of the new objects) computed

Let C[X]−\C[X]^- be the functions on a G~\tilde G-set XX that are odd under −I-I; for a new object it has dimension ∣X∣/2|X|/2, and its constituents are faithful. Then

C[16]−≅4⊕4ˉ,C[48]−≅4⊕4ˉ⊕8⊕8,C[112]−≅2 (4⊕4ˉ⊕6+⊕6−⊕8),\begin{aligned}\C[16]^-&\cong\mathbf 4\oplus\bar{\mathbf 4},\\\C[48]^-&\cong\mathbf 4\oplus\bar{\mathbf 4}\oplus\mathbf 8\oplus\mathbf 8,\\\C[112]^-&\cong2\,(\mathbf 4\oplus\bar{\mathbf 4}\oplus\mathbf 6_+\oplus\mathbf 6_-\oplus\mathbf 8),\end{aligned}

and C[336]−\C[336]^- contains each faithful irreducible representation as often as its dimension. The spin bundle lives over the seven points, an object pulled back from GG, and its sections are 6±⊕8\mathbf 6_\pm\oplus\mathbf 8; the two smallest faithful representations, 4\mathbf 4 and 4ˉ\bar{\mathbf 4}, do not occur there, and are carried by the smallest new object, the sixteen square classes.

Example(The new objects in the Weil representation) computed

The Weil representation of SL⁡(2,7)\SL(2,7) on the functions on F7\F_7 splits into the even functions, an irreducible 4\mathbf 4 on which −I-I acts as −1-1, and the odd functions, on which −I-I acts trivially and which are Klein’s representation ρ\rho itself. In the 4\mathbf 4, the orbit of δ0\delta_0 is sixteen vectors ±vc\pm v_c, one pair over each point cc of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7): the object of size 16. Vectors of the plane fixed by the odd lift of C3C_3, off two lines, have the object of size 112 as their orbit, and its automorphism group C4C_4 acts on an orbit of eigenvectors by the scalars iki^k. A vector with trivial stabilizer gives the regular object.

No vector of the 4\mathbf 4 has stabilizer the odd lift of C7C_7, so the object of size 48 is a forced gap there. It is found in another representation: the forty-eight vectors ζ6kec\zeta_6^ke_c of the monomial principal series Ind⁡BG~α\operatorname{Ind}_B^{\tilde G}\alpha, irreducible of dimension 8, are the object of size 48.